Frist of all, I knew promising a weekly review would be risky.
I just didn't think I'd fail in the third week. Sigh. So, I am going back to promising random reviews, especially in light of some super fun and super time consuming family projects going on at the moment which will unfortunately negatively impact my reading and writing time. Please bear with me!!
On to the Book of the Week!
Remember way back when when I was so anti Audiobooks?
Welcome to the first time I have thought, man, I should be listening to this one instead of reading the book.
Wow.
I will come back to that in a minute. First of all I want to say that I am firmly in the camp that this is NOT a YA book. I cannot believe it was categorized that way. There are some really hard themes here, lots of loss of family and support and stability, and drug abuse and reservation politics and a violent sexual assault on a young woman that was almost skimmed over it was written so fast, but still was very disturbing to me. Did it have impact on the story? Well, yes, but still, that doesn't mean I had to like it. I have two teenage/young adult daughters so that sort of thing is a trigger for me personally.
Ok, moving on. I wish I had listened to this one because of all the beautiful names and hard pronunciation problems I had with reading it. My book club will review this book soon so maybe I will take that opportunity to listen to a book I have already read! I took a lot of notes on this book, trying to keep the family and the scandal Daunis was born into straight. There are a lot of characters in this book! Her two grandmothers - one white, one Native American Anishinaabe - push and pull her between two worlds and we see that relationship and identity strain from the very start of the novel. We learn about the difference between a descendant and an enrolled member of their community, about how dreams are so important, about sacrifice and secrets and doing the right thing. There is a murder, a witness, and some undercover cops, and Daunis is asked to go undercover too, to help them break up a meth ring, which could end up backfiring on her already fractured family. There are overbearing parents and there is racism and prejudice against a biracial girl who has trouble finding her place. We do get a nice full circle ending, but this is a hard read. Fascinating in its description of life on an Ojibwe reservation, the injustice of tribal laws and/or the US Federal law's inability to prosecute crimes on reservation land, too. There is just so much going on.
Welcome to Life.
I gave this one five stars on Goodreads, so I don't mean for this expanded review to sound negative. I would direct you to other reviews on Goodreads by Brandann Hill-Mann, luce and Jessica Woodbury and don't miss the comments under those reviews; there is a lot of good information and explanation from Hill-Mann, whose hometown is Sault Ste Marie, Michigan, where the book is set.
UPDATE:
My book club met last night. We all LOVED this book and two members said it was now one of their all time favorites. We all heartily agreed that this was not really a Young Adult book, and had a great discussion about what a YA book really is. For us, it is not solely defined by having a teenage protagonist (see: Demon Copperhead. I would not give that book to a 12 year old. An 18 year old? Maybe. But I know 50 year old women who had a hard time with that brilliant, wonderful, heartbreaking book - and still my favorite of the year). One definition I found for YA was: a book for ages 12-18. Say, What??? In what (modern) world is a 13 year old considered an adult?? Just call it what it is - teen fiction - and keep the adult themes for adults at least 21. I mean, yes, I understand that every kid has a different maturity level and that we should never ban books and parents should encourage all kinds of reading. But can we at least keep them age appropriate? Do we want 12 year old girls, or boys, reading about violent or even non violent rape, for a perpetrator who legally got away with it, and having them think that is ok? Impressionable minds and all that. Just my humble opinion. What is yours??
No comments:
Post a Comment